The power of choice. That’s what Johnsen Insurance delivers. As an independent insurance agency, we shop among many insurance companies to find the best policies for your needs at the best rates possible – giving you options no ordinary agency can. In just a few minutes you can have the Johnsen Insurance team find you the best coverage for the lowest costs, proving what the power of choice is really about.

Insurance Baraboo Storefront


Have one of our insurance professionals contact you.

Personal Quote

reCAPTCHA is required.
Business Quote

reCAPTCHA is required.

Auto, Home, Business, Life, Health Insurance

Our Happy Customers

  • In our industry we rely heavily on our insurance agent. Johnsen Insurance is aware of that and is excellent in meeting our business needs. It is exceptionally useful to have such an attentive vendor.

    Cheryl Seymour Deppe Transit LLC Controller
  • Johnsen Insurance has provided my home & auto insurance for years and always in my best interest - would not consider going elsewhere!

    Jane Z.
  • Johnsen Insurance are the dynamic partner that you want for your business or personal needs. Their knowledge, personal attention and commitment will make any area or issue achievable. They view you as family as you will of them; Circus World is very proud to be part of the Johnsen Insurance family. Their support of the Baraboo community is profound and makes us all better.

    Scott O'Donnell Circus World Director
  • I have insured my business with Johnsen Insurance for over 36 years and have always received stellar service!

    Roy Mjelde Top Hat of Baraboo & Madison Owner
  • Glenville Timberwrights has been relying on Johnsen Insurance since 2011 and we have been extremely happy with their service. Bill handles all of our business insurance from auto to Work Comp and do a great job. They take care of all of our requests quickly and with the utmost efficiency and courtesy.

    Les Pennington Glenville Timberwrights Controller
  • The Al. Ringling Mansion has been insured through Johnsen Insurance for several years now and we wouldn't have it any other way. Great value and great customer care!

    Joe Colossa AL. Ringling Mansion Owner
  • Johnsen Insurance has been so much more than our insurance agency. They have gone above and beyond to ensure that we have the best coverage possible for our unique historical property, as well as helped guide us on best practices to maximize onsite safety and minimize risk. They have provided us with incredible, highly personalized service. Both Bill and Mike Johnsen have shown repeatedly that they truly care about the theatre through their countless hours of volunteering. Not many insurance agents will go that far for a client!!

    Stephanie Miller-Lamb Al. Ringling Theatre Executive Director
  • Being a small business owner and having never ending questions about the new discoveries and changes in my field. I have found Johnsen Insurance to be not only knowledgeable in the field, but also incredibly focused on helping their clients.

    Taffy Harrison Vintage Port Coffee & Catering

A picture is worth a thousand words

Mike & Bill Johnsen for insurance Baraboo

New Johnsen Insurance sign mock up

Insurance in beautiful downtown Baraboo

Sauk County Corthouse tower

Contact Us

Send us an email and we'll get back to you, asap.

Not readable? Change text. captcha txt